Paris Childress and Simon Young of Question.Marketing argue that the next ad format may be a business agent paid on a lead or a sale, not a standard cost-per-click unit. On The GEO Show they unpack that idea, then look at Google's November 19, 2026 desktop homepage sidebar into AI Mode, HUMAN Security's October agent-traffic data, and Simon's forthcoming AI visibility tool report.
The next ad format may be a business agent that can join a conversation and get paid on a lead or a sale, not a banner or a standard cost-per-click unit. On this week's GEO Show, Paris Childress and Simon Young of Question.Marketing treat that idea as the argument of the week, then look at a second, more immediate change: on November 19, 2026, Google began rolling out a collapsible sidebar on the desktop google.com homepage so people can reopen recent AI Mode chats. If that agentic ad model works, how long can a cost-per-click internet hold?
The episode was recorded on Friday, November 20, 2026, the day after Google's announcement and two days after Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella's DealBook Summit remarks on agents. It is the recurring Friday wrap-up, not a finished investigation. Several figures and predictions in the conversation are scoped below.
Paris connects today's agent experiments to a second shift already visible in ChatGPT's business profiles: an agent that can be trained, inserted into conversations, and pointed at a sale. He thinks that model, not a homepage sidebar alone, is what eventually forces Google to go further.
Your new ad format is your agent. That's it.
That line is Paris's forecast of the direction, not a published ChatGPT or Google rate card. Hypothetical examples in the episode, including a $100 qualified lead or a 10% or 20% share of a sale, should stay labeled as examples.
Google is rolling out a collapsible left sidebar on the desktop homepage that lists recent AI Mode threads, with a path to start a new thread or jump back into an old one. Robby Stein announced the desktop global rollout. Search Engine Roundtable, The Verge, and Search Engine Land reported it on November 19. Paris walks through a Search Engine Roundtable example on screen. The coverage, and Paris's own reading, is desktop only. The sidebar is still rolling out, and it is not a switch that makes AI Mode the default.
Even so, the show's argument is that any change to google.com is worth watching. A history rail on the homepage makes AI Mode feel less like a separate mode and more like a place you are expected to return to. If more sessions start or resume inside AI Mode, brands are judged less on a blue-link ranking and more on whether they are understandable, cited, and recommendable in that thread.
Paris describes a split already in motion. Some platforms are racing to let agents pay, log in, and complete tasks. Other companies are putting up a wall. Satya Nadella, speaking at The New York Times DealBook Summit on November 18, said, "If you don't accept the agent, somebody else will." Those remarks also addressed Amazon's decision to block shopping agents, with a contrast to more open platforms such as Shopify. Paris also said United Airlines is not letting agents book flights. That United claim was not independently confirmed for this kit and should not be treated as a verified policy in the show notes beyond what was said on the recording.
Paris cites HUMAN Security's October 2026 State of Agentic Traffic report. On the sites and apps HUMAN protects, Meta Muse accounted for 59% of agent requests and ChatGPT Agent about 16%. October volume was about 2.6 times September. 1.9% of requests landed on checkout or payment pages. Two limits matter. The dataset is requests on HUMAN's customer sites, not the whole web, and a request that reaches a checkout page is not a completed purchase. Muse was still US-only when the episode was recorded.
Simon is close to publishing a tool study that Paris expects to see first. His early headline is that many tools decide the prompts for you, which can change the visibility score, and that some have added branded prompts and then emailed that the score improved. He also saw prompt injections on some vendor pages. This is a forthcoming report, not a finished public paper, and it should be attributed to him.
00:00:46 Simon says the main issue with many AI visibility tools is that they decide the prompts for you.
00:14:02 Paris walks through HUMAN Security's October figures, including Muse at 59% of agent requests on protected sites.
00:15:39 Paris quotes Nadella: if you don't accept the agent, somebody else will.
00:22:51 Paris flags the Google homepage sidebar as a major change to a sacred place on the internet, then shows the example.
00:29:38 Paris argues that an agentic ad format at ChatGPT is the moment Google will have to follow rather than lead.
The conversation also includes a personal aside about unexpected Grok Bot usage and a closing discussion of Anthropic's November 19 IPO. Those remarks are not the editorial throughline. Valuation figures from the IPO should be handled carefully: the stock opened sharply higher and briefly approached a 2 trillion dollar fully diluted value, then closed about 17% above the offer price.
Paris: Hey, everybody, and welcome back to The GEO Show, brought to you by GEO Forge, full self-driving for AI visibility. It's Friday, November 20th, and that means I'm back at it with Simon Young from Question Marketing. Simon, how are you doing today?
Simon: Feeling a lot better than I did the rest of the week. But, um, yeah, I'm, I'm s- I've ... Well, another week burning a ton of credits, but it's, it's really good. Um, we talked before about the state of AEO, GEO software and where it's at, and the report that I'm gonna release, and I'm just about ready to start publishing that, and you'll be You'll probably be the first person to see it
Paris: Great. Any, any spoiler alerts that you can, anything that you can tease us with?
Simon: there's, there's, there's a lot of confusion. Um, a lot of the tools are deciding the prompts for you, which is probably seems like the main issue
Paris: Mm-hmm. Yeah, because those are not the right prompts, and they don't know enough about your business
Simon: No. So
Paris: or your buyers
Simon: one of the biggest findings is a lot of them, you know, the pa- the proper tools like yours will go into depth and work it out, but
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: of these ones which, uh, sort of seem like they're vibe coded or just pulling data from SEO or wherever they're getting it from, they're not doing it in the right way. Um, and then they, you know, they chuck a ba- bunch of terms in there which then changes the, you know, the visibility completely,
Paris: Oh, yeah
Simon: really disseminate between the two. Then they'll send you an email, um, you know, with saying, "Oh, your," you know, "your score's increased." And some of those include, "Therefore, we've included some brand terms,"
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: just feels like a sales pitch at that point,
Paris: That's...
Simon: it is
Paris: You mean so they're-- what they're doing is they're starting to s- over time sprinkle in brand, branded prompts so that they can show you a increasing share of voice?
Simon: Not a lot of them, but it has been seen. And
Paris: Uff
Simon: the other worry, one of the other worrying things, and we talked about this a little bit before, was some of them are sprinkling prompt, you know, injections into some of the pages that they're landing you on. So
Paris: Mm-hmm
Simon: know what they are ... My, my tool obviously didn't follow any of that and then left it alone, but might be another study to do at a later date to see what they are, you know, what they are injecting or trying to get you to do
Paris: Mm-hmm. Wow.
Simon: got
Paris: Hmm.
Simon: quite a lot to get through today, haven't we?
Paris: Yeah. Yeah, we do. I think, uh, I mean, the first two topics are very similar because they're about agents, but we-- let's start there. Um, we're seeing the, the big platforms moving very, very fast now to give agents the ability to pay in a secure way, to pay and make transactions, to make phone calls, and, uh, and, and to do all the types of logins and security checks necessary to get validated. And the second, the second story, which is related to that, is it's about the agent front door because still not everyone is letting agents in. And we're-- right now, I, I don't think this is sustainable at all, but we're in this world where a-- there are some places that are welcoming and opening their doors to agents, and there are other places that are completely blocking and saying, "Nope, you can't come in." And, uh, it's creating a-- it, it's really just creating a, a, a world of haves and have-nots, I guess, because I think the consumer trend here is moving very quickly to, uh, agents. Um, and, and I think it's gonna, it's gonna be, um... If an agent's gonna research, uh, let's say a holiday for me, I'm gonna be very comfortable having it complete the bookings, the, the hotel reservation, the flights, the, the activities. Uh, I would be happy to have the agent buy, especially buy these, uh, non-discretionary items that I'm constantly buying, like my pet food, my washing detergent, um, stuff that I'm, uh, that, that I'm always getting and replenishing. So anyway, I'm gonna, I'm gonna turn it over to you, Simon. I mean, what, what is your sense of how fast this is moving, and how does this change GEO? Is GEO, the way we optimize and try to position our websites, our brands for GEO, is that gonna change now that, uh, it's gonna be people that are the-- I mean, it is gonna be more agents that are gonna be going and operating on behalf of people instead of people going in and prompting proactively into LLMs?
Simon: It could, yeah, I could, it could well be that the agents then... Well, in theory, the agent sits more in a MCP or API layer, doesn't it? It will be talking in the
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: rather than physically opening chats, I would imagine.
Paris: Yeah. I think the big difference is that it's proactive. And so a lot-- in a lot of cases, an agent, an ag- an agent would update you on something which might trigger a conversation for it to go and do something. But there isn't this, there isn't the same starting point of a prompt like, uh, "Show me the best holiday ideas for XYZ." Instead of the user initiating that, maybe the agent says, "Hey, I know that you, I know that you're, y- you've already-- you just got approved for these two weeks of vacation. How about we start planning your vacation? You want some ideas?" Instead of the, the user going with a prompt. And that, uh, that's gonna be different, I think. You know? Then the agent really gets to decide which brands, which brand should I show and put in front of this, uh, this user
Simon: It'll be, it, it will be really interesting to see how quickly it moves. I know obviously the space is moving quickly from one side, i.e., you know, people like Shopify, et cetera, wanting to allow amounts of activity into shops. Um, I think you have to... I think you s- you said you have to put a certain file in or you have to let it, know, talk. You have to give it permission or I think it
Paris: Mhm.
Simon: But,
Paris: Ja
Simon: in terms of the general public, I don't know how quick that uptake will necessarily be to a fully agentic uptake because, you know, you and I, we, we do a little bit of that at the moment, right? And we're hopefully a way ahead of most people. But at what point does mass adoption happen? That's the... You know, that's, that will be the interesting point of where your
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: You know, like take, take for example my wife, right? Who's... She would just search on... She might use ChatGPT a little bit, um, but she'd search on Google. She doesn't do an awful lot more than that. Nothing against doing that 'cause it's probably what the average person does. But at what point does she then go, "Well, I wanna talk to my device," or, "I'm gonna type into it." Or the device then says, yeah, like you say, "Well, you've, you know, you've got, you've got a couple of weeks coming up," or, you know, well, we've actually got our kids coming home from university at Christmas so, you know, does it, does it say, you know, "Here's some ideas of where you can take them on days out."
Paris: Yeah. I, I think that the big change is the proactivity. It's gon- it's gonna be-- The AI is prompting you now instead of you prompting it, basically. And when, when the human is no longer the one initiating some portion of the prompts, um, let's, let's try to bring it back to GEO here. What, what changes in GEO? Am I still, um... It just-- Right now, I can't think of anything. I, I can't think of anything that I would change from what we're doing now and what would happen, let's say, in GEO Forge, where you have a knowledge base that's grounding content so you can have high information gain. You're publishing content at, uh, at, as, at, at higher volumes than usual just so that you can really try to get all the information out there and train, train those agents. You're publishing on third parties as well because agents, I think, are gonna do the same thing that LLMs do, which is they're, they're gonna look to validate your brand's claims around the web. So I don't think anything's gonna change, but it is something interesting to think about, um, how the, you know, the optimization practice is, uh, is affected. Um, but, but I think the major, the major change in the behavior between the human and the, and the AI is that the AI is gonna be the one initiating a lot of conversations now instead of just reacting to a user's prompt.
Simon: But do you not think, and I think this is something you're gonna come on to talk about a little bit later in, so I'll not put a spoiler in, but
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: you not think that most businesses are completely unprepared for where this is going?
Paris: Yeah, probably so. Mm-hmm
Simon: You know, the fact that, yes, I've got a website, yes, I've got some information out there, I might have a blog, um, everything else might be a jungle or a, you know, like bits and pieces that have accumulated historically about me online.
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: we then surely move into a world where fast-forward to the quicker you get a proper agent of your own for your own property and your own
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: base built that is able to interact with the other agents, you know, surely that- that's the race because
Paris: Yeah
Simon: will need... We talked about, a little bit about Google My Business or Google Business Places as it's now, but
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: then moves to a point where, well, you know, we know a certain amount about you. Imagine I got a message from an a- from, from an L- LLM or an agent that says, "Simon, I wanna do an interview with you about your business and how you can help and where you work, and talk to me." Well,
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: then did that or ignored it, if you ignore it, surely you're at a huge disadvantage. But
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: then move into a world where I talk to, I talk to it all day long, I
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: be bothered, then I'm falling behind? I don't know.
Paris: Yeah. I don't know. I, I think there's gonna be a lot more emphasis now placed on the, the business profiles. I mean, Google, Google My Business, I think now a Google Business Profile it's called, um, that's existed forever. Um, and that's always been important, especially for local businesses. But now Google doesn't really have a horse in the race yet for the A- the personal AI assistants. I think they're ... I think it's coming soon. The, the, it might have been Spark, this thing S- Gemini Spark, but then that doesn't seem to be sticking. So Google Business Profiles- Mm-hmm.
Simon: I've gone in... Sorry to interrupt, but I've gone
Paris: Yeah
Simon: today, and it's probably the first time I've been in for a few weeks, and I had a whole bunch of gems that I use in there. And push now is that they are trying to give you skills. All my gems have disappeared. I
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: Gemini, "Well, where, where are all my gems that I built?"
Paris: Yeah
Simon: It feels like Google is just flip-flopping all over the place trying to... I don't think it necessarily has a plan. you would hope that, know, one of the biggest companies on Earth would have it all mapped out
Paris: Yeah. Well, they-- I think they are following OpenAI here because OpenAI is killing off custom GPTs, and I think, uh, Gemini is-- The, the Gems were the same thing, so I guess they're following suit. But, um, what's interesting now is that Google is very much having to play catch-up here, and they've been the innovators. I mean, Google practically invented AI basically i-in the context of the internet, and, uh, and it's really just so ironic that they're now, they're now chasing other, other people and having to play catch-up. Um, I mean, and Google, Google Business Profile is an example of that because ChatGPT launched their business hub with ChatGPT business profiles just a week ago, and that has already, I think, leapfrogged with more features than a Google Business Profile because you have, you have, uh, product listings, so it's kind of like Google Shopping feed inside of there, and then you have the agent, and you can, you can train an agent who's gonna be inserted into conversations who can sell for you, and Google Business Profiles don't, don't have that. So, um, I think-
Simon: it's not a
Paris: Mm-hmm
Simon: see it coming though. But like, like you say, in OpenAI, I take it, have you applied for partner status?
Paris: Uh, to claim my business?
Simon: No. So I've claimed my business, but I've also applied and been approved for OpenAI partner status, and within that portal, there are
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: of opportunities for agencies to with clients to onboard projects or say what you're working on that's gonna be innovative in AI, and
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: actively to fund that activity. So for example, GeoForge, if you submit it through that part- uh, partner portal a case in point, you will get a portion of that funded if they approve it
Paris: Mm-hmm. Well, what gets funded?
Simon: hundreds of thousands of dollars, like per project available
Paris: Wow, interesting. Because it
Simon: you. I'll send, I'll send you some more info, 'cause I've been, I've been having a play and I actually said to Claude... So this was the, this was the funny piece, right? I went into my OpenAI partner portal, had my Claude sidebar open, and asked Claude what's the best things to do in it
Paris: Mm-hmm
Simon: it to go through the whole thing, and it found all the submit this project.
Paris: Wow. I-- That's the first time I'm hearing about this partner portal. Um, but that's, that's fascinating. Yeah, we'll have to do a side, uh, discussion around that. Hmm. Yeah. Well, but back to the, back to the agents thing. Um, right now the most popular agent is Meta Muse actually, by, by a large portion. Muse is actually... And I, I reported on this this week, uh, and let me read this snippet. Uh, there was, uh, the source is Human Security's, uh, customer sites in October. But Meta Muse made 59% of agent requests, and th-this is a, in a group, it's in a large group of websites, so there's some kind of a sample here. I presume it's pr-pretty good sample. But 59% of all agent requests were from Meta Muse. ChatGPT's agents were just 16%, and then I don't know about the rest. But, um, the, the requests are growing very fast. I mean, so October had grown 2.6x month over month. But the caveat here is that still, even though the agent requests are, are just spiking right now, uh, only 1.9% of these agents reached the checkout page, so I mean, com- meaning they completed a purchase
Simon: this is all US data, right? 'Cause I can't get Muse yet
Paris: It, uh, this, this absolute- Yeah, it has to be US 'cause Muse is a US only. Yeah Yeah.
Simon: But
Paris: And then
Simon: to see that it is getting to checkouts and actually transacting
Paris: Yeah. Yeah. And then what I reported on in today's episode is that Satya Nadella, Nadella, the CEO of Microsoft, said, I think he said this yesterday at a big conference, that if you don't accept the agent, somebody else will. Just very, very direct there, huh? Yeah
Simon: Like, why, why would you put a wall up around... this is Amazon's biggest mistake if they block- if they're gonna block agents
Paris: and so is United Airlines. That's the biggest, that is the biggest US airlines, US airline company. They're not letting agents book flight tickets, I guess for security reasons
Simon: I'll just put a no index on the front of everything, you know, and just drop out of the internet and not, not bother and put myself out of business. Like, that's what it feels like
Paris: Yeah. Yeah. But getting, getting back to the assistants, so we were talking about the ChatGPT business profile already having one-upped, at least one-upped the, the Google business profile because they have, um, they have, they have product listings in there, and they have the agent you can build. But what about Meta? So we-- I just read that Meta's p- practically 60% of, of this e- emerging market of AI, personal AI assistants is Meta, Muse. Meta has a... I mean, businesses have Facebook pages, I guess, but what is the equivalent for Meta of the Google business page or the ChatGPT business profile?
Simon: I suppose your, you know, your company business page is what's
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: a static listing as it stands,
Paris: Your, your Face- your, your Facebook page for your, for your business? Or is it Instagram? Yeah
Simon: yeah, one or both. One or both. Obviously, they like to have
Paris: They can pull both, yeah. Mm-hmm
Simon: thing that happened to my wife this week, um, she started getting lots more WhatsApp ads. So WhatsApp itself sending offers, direct to her, which was supposedly, you know, tar- or not targeted, but relevant. Um, and she's like, "Well, why am... Like, I'm gonna block..." the, and
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: is WhatsApp, right? So I said, obviously, Meta owns WhatsApp, and that's one of the things that they're using. So
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: part of the, you know, their plan is to use your, your mobile or your WhatsApp communication to come in and then, be part of that whole agentic mix
Paris: Ah, okay. So they might actually split the organic conversation. They, they might keep the Meta Muse conversation completely organic, and then if, if, if they decide that we wanna show you some ads now, they might just send you those ads through WhatsApp
Simon: Maybe.
Paris: Huh.
Simon: I don't, I don't
Paris: That seems a little bit clunky. Hmm
Simon: got really annoyed with it pretty quickly, so
Paris: Yeah. So they just came out of nowhere? Huh.
Simon: so your traditional consumer, I, I think the bigger question here is are we all gonna react to being sold to continually? Like, how often is it gonna jump in and say, "Paris, um, can see that this might be interesting to you," or, you know, that, that whole piece other than,
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: thinks it knows what you want,
Paris: Yeah.
Simon: but do I
Paris: Well, there, there, there should be a, there should be a proactivity dial where if I wanted, if I wanted to just tell my agents, "Just shut up and stop." You know, I, I wanna do this with Grok Bot a lot of times. I mean, if I open my Grok Bot right now, I guarantee you I, I've got probably 30 messages that I haven't caught up on across eight, eight Grok Bots, and I haven't-- I mean, there is no ability to do this, but at some point, if your agent just becomes too pushy and too proactive, you need to be able to turn the dial down and say, "Just I, I need less, you know. Just give me less. All I want is just the, the things that, um, that I really need to know about anything where I might be losing money or... But don't, don't always be pitching me ideas for, uh, activities and shopping and, and goods."
Simon: Well, we spoke in the week about your, you know, you, you lost money to GrokBot. I've now
Paris: Jan
Simon: to GrokBot. so that if, you know, if people are listening and, um, want to understand what happened, we've both had GrokBot usage that we hadn't, in theory, authorized.
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: you know, I woke up one- I paid off my... So I've got a limit on what I, you know, I allow it to spend over and above, so I've got a cap,
Paris: Yeah
Simon: I paid off my usage from last month. Um, albeit it was only £37, right? It wasn't much. that was just to free up and get going again for a, like, a Monday when it, my usage wasn't gonna reset until lunchtime. So I paid it on the Sunday in, in anticipation I would need to use it the Monday morning, and I woke up in the morning, and it had used another $100. And
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: There was nothing running that would've done that. Um, not as far as I'm concerned, you know. And it, and it now won't tell me how it spent those credits.
Paris: Yeah
Simon: and it then says, "Well, I can draft you an email to support." And I've done that, and I've done that on several occasions now where I feel like it's not followed instructions, it's burned a ton of usage, it hasn't used a cursor model where I wanted it to, et
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: And it'll apologize to you. So it'll say, "Oh, sorry, Simon.
Paris: Well, m-my, yeah, my case was not 100, 100 pounds, but it was about $850 over, over just during one night. And, uh, so it was really, a really bad case. And what I had done, I hadn't realized this, but when you set up GroqBot for the first time, the default setting on the monthly... The, there is no monthly limit. The default setting is basically, uh, just unlimited.
Simon: the taps on.
Paris: Yeah. And I did, and, and I missed it. I missed that when I set it up. I didn't, I didn't go in and see that, and it was too late because I had been... S-someone had gotten into my account and, uh, and actually it showed up in the usage as, uh, as Claude Opus usage, not as GroqBot usage. Because GroqBot can use other models actually
Simon: I think this is, this is gonna be one of the biggest problems as we go forward is, know, fraud within agents. You know, like I think there was
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: you sent me earlier about of sites that are up there are getting cited and are not necessarily offering the correct information, or something along those lines.
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: there's, there will be a huge problem. You know, I know for example, Muse is free, isn't it, at the moment for people to use? But in theory it comes to a point where they either charge for it or, you know, like YouTube, if you want the ad-free version you have to pay. Well,
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: to pay for the ad-free version of...
Paris: Yeah. Yeah. Um, well, Simon, I've got another topic to, to pivot over into, which I think is, uh, another interesting one, and, uh, that I reported on this today, which is that Google, the Google homepage now on desktop, which is a sacred... This is a sacred place on the internet. Um, they have now included a new sidebar which gives you a recap, uh, a recap of your history of AI mode conversations on the google.com homepage, which is the, you know, the clean, you know, the, the, the very, very sanctimonious place. So it's a ma- it's a major change. Anytime Google touches the, their google.com homepage, it's a really big deal. And, uh, I think I can pull up some, um... I'm gonna share the screen. I'm gonna-- I think I have some examples to show here from Search Engine Roundtable. Let's pull this up Okay. Is that, uh... I think, yeah, it's there. So here's google.com. But let's play this video and see. So now, um, here's the panel. There's the recent... These are my recent searches here, and Let's see. If you close that, uh, I'm gonna see what happens. I guess there's-- that's basically it. But AI mode is now
Simon: it's being played with, isn't it? They're definitely experimenting
Paris: yeah. Left sidebar
Simon: it doesn't look any different to me. It's normal Google
Paris: Oh, it-- I think they haven't done this on mobile. It's desktop only. But yeah, they're, they're definitely experimenting for sure. And, um, I'm just gonna play this video one more time on, uh, full screen here. Yeah, so you open that sidebar, and then there's your recent AI mode chats. And when you click into one of them, you can see you're going right into AI mode. So this is a, another very, very direct pathway from classic Google into Google AI mode. And I think what's happening-- I'm gonna, uh, turn off the screen share
Simon: not brave enough to go full AI, are
Paris: Yeah, th-they're tip-tippy-toeing. Yeah. They're just tippy-toeing in and testing this thing, testing that thing. But I think what is gonna force their hand, eventually force their hand to switch on AI mode default, is gonna be ChatGPT's success with a- with their ad model, with ChatGPT Ads, because what we see in ChatGPT Business Profile is this agent who is waiting to be trained so that it can go into conversations and sell, and that is gonna be the format. It's not gonna be display ads. It's not gonna be a cost-per-click model. It's gonna be a, uh, it's gonna be a pay-per-lead or commission-based, a pay-per-performance model. And once that's set up, why would anyone stay on Google Ads and keep paying for clicks if I can move over to Google-- to ChatGPT, and I can pay $100 for a qualified lead, or I can pay 10% out of every sale? That de-risks the whole thing for me
Simon: they must have seen it coming,
Paris: Ja
Simon: If, if they're not smart enough to see where it's gonna end up, there must be a chart
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: with a, you know, a flow chart that says this to this, to this, to where it goes, right? They have to have
Paris: Yeah. And at the end of that flowchart it says, "We're screwed."
Simon: Well, yeah, but well, actually, I pro- there must be some significant numbers in terms of ad revenue across the top of it as well, and at what
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: we actually kick ourselves you know, we cut off our main revenue stream and go full, "You must do this instead"?
Paris: Ja.
Simon: what, what are Google Ads agencies sat there doing at the moment? They must be
Paris: They better learn ChatGPT ads really quick. I mean, that's what we're doing. We, we, we have to be able to serve ChatGPT ads, and clients are asking for it too. Yeah. "Well, help me get into test ChatGPT ads. It's new, and we wanna see how it works." And the ChatGPT ads interface is, uh, it's way, way behind Google Ads. Uh, it's very primitive.
Simon: it?
Paris: Yeah
Simon: Yeah
Paris: gonna change because they've hired-- they've probably hired a bunch of Google Ads people and other, other people from the industry, and they're gonna close the gap. And I think that they probably don't even care that their back end doesn't look so good because they're already thinking, "Look, the model is gonna be all about these agents." You're, you're, you're, you're not gonna ask a user to come in and build creative. You're not gonna ask a user to build the audiences or to generate headlines or, uh, definitely not selecting keywords. Forget about that. They're not even gonna select the topics. They're just gonna say, "Here's my agent, and you plug my agent in wherever you think my agent can make a sale. I don't care. You figure out my personas. You might know more about my personas than I do. You might discover people that wanna buy from me that I've never even thought of before, so go and do it, and I'll give you, you know, I'll give you 20% of every sale. I'll give you X amount per lead, per conversion." And so what-- You don't need much of an interface for that. You just need to focus on your agent, pr- really training your agent well in your Google, in your ChatGPT business profile. Give it as much context as possible. It e-effectively, that becomes your, your, your new website, really, because ChatGPT says, "We don't wanna spend all these resour-re-resources crawling your, all these websites over and over and over,
Simon: No,
Paris: and we don't wanna rely on Google's index also to do real-time search. We want all these websites to rebuild themselves for an AI-first world inside of our business profiles so that we can just draw all the information from there." And that becomes the n-the new ChatGPT index of the web. It's their own business profile
Simon: but that's why, you know, we don't understand why Google hasn't already, you know... Well, I know it would be the biggest shift ever in search, right? And well, I know we debate whether SEO exists in the future. I don't think it does just for that reason, because every single surface will have its own optimized a- agentic platform, as in not a website
Paris: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it's gonna be all agent to agent because I have my personal agent and every brand has their branded agent and those are gonna be the two agents. These two middlemen are gonna be the ones that are transacting. Yeah, in some cases you even tell your agent, huh?
Simon: Huge, huge
Simon: But like when, when, but then let, look, when though, right? At what point? How long? When will it be that Google will actually go, "Okay, guys, hands up.
Paris: I, I'll tell you when. I'll tell you exactly when. It's when ChatGPT rolls out this new ad interface, which is basically agentic, the agentic advertising platform, and they're saying, "Now all the agents are gonna be... Your new ad format is your agent. That's it." And then when ChatGPT-- When-- That will kill cost per click advertising, and then Google will have to say, "Okay, it-- we have no choice now. Uh, Google Ads, Google AdWords, Google Ads as we've known it is now, is now done. We have to now follow ChatGPT's first mover. Uh, we, we have to follow their innovation instead of leading innovation, and we have to allow, uh, our customers to build agents inside of my Google Business profiles and do the same thing." And, uh, and what they're gonna see is that that's not gonna monetize as well as a cost per click model because the cost per click model was brilliant. You had an auction and everybody would bid and bid and, and, and raise the price constantly, and you didn't have to take any of the risk as Google. But now Google's gonna have to shift that risk onto themselves because they're gonna have to say, "Well, we don't get paid unless, uh, the business' agent can close a sale, and that's really risky for us, so we have to make sure that the, the business can, uh, empower this agent and, and arm this agent to make sales and do well, and we'll, we'll try our best." But if Google moves from a cost per click model to a cost per action model, that could be, that, that could be massively disruptive, you know?
Simon: it's ga-
Paris: But,
Simon: over for
Paris: but-
Simon: gen agencies at that point as well. All
Paris: Yeah, yeah. Any lead gen agency, they're done. Yeah, of course, because Google becomes the lead gen agency
Simon: And that's the way it should b- it should have always been. Like,
Paris: Yeah
Simon: we all know that f- probably 50% of your Google Ads budget down the toilet. does because of,
Paris: Yeah.
Simon: useless
Paris: fraud. Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Simon: Not, not necessarily even fraud, just for the fact that people are browsing and then clicking, and they were never in a buying mood anyway, but they're clicking your ad
Paris: Yeah. Yeah, they're, they're, they're doing research, but they're not ready to buy
Simon: paid two or three or four times, right? People click two or three or four sites, so
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: one can win, or e- even if they are winning, but still people will click two, three, four sponsored links, and Google gets paid every single time.
Paris: Yeah. Yeah
Simon: or even worse than that, I've chosen, which is my fault, I've chosen the wrong keywords. You know, I've ... I was ... So I've got, um, I've got a new client. They have a very generic name. Um, I'm not gonna say who it is, because it's a brand new client for me, it wouldn't be fair. But, um, and I haven't signed the contract yet, but it's gonna ... It's
Paris: Don't say it. Don't say it
Simon: so I'm not gonna say it, right? But the, the client's name's very generic, and they're running ads, and a chunk of their clicks go to, um, something noth- nothing, is not related to their industry at all, right?
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: their generic word in their name. Now, Google should have really put something in place to stop that years ago, right? They
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: They have got the tools there to say, "Somebody is browsing and searching a topic, and they've now ... They're going to click on an ad. We know, we know that that's not what they need, but they've just spent the money for the advertiser." For
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: poor. You know, that is poor cus- that's a poor experience, know, for the, for the advertiser, but also for the person who was browsing, because they end up on something they di- they go backwards straightaway but the money got spent. Well, Google's like, "Happy days, we got paid." Well, everybody else had a bad experience, so
Paris: Yeah
Simon: promise was we would have the best experience, and we're now gonna get that with AI. So Google now has to say, "Well, look, ad revenue is shrinking. Um, know we can do the ..." Like, they've gotta be brave. They've got to go and
Paris: Yeah
Simon: "Here's the full platform that does everything you've ever dreamed of,"
Paris: Yeah
Simon: the opportunity to do- I'm sure they must have it built. They must
Paris: Yeah. I, I think it's all built and they're just trying to postpone rolling it out because it's g- it's gonna be the biggest thing that they've ever done to disrupt themselves. And you always have the... I don't know if it's the innovator's di- dilemma. I think it's called the innovator's dilemma, but it's basically either you disrupt yourself or someone else, someone else is gonna disrupt you, and right now that's the choice. OpenAI is, is, is right there, right there ready to disrupt them. I mean, they're, they are gonna launch this, this ad format that is gonna be an, i- it's gonna be a native agentic advertising format, and it's perfect for, for ChatGPT. And so Google can wait for that to happen, and they can be forced to copy them and follow them, or they can just say, "Look, uh, we're-- it's time for us to, to flip the switch. We've gotta pull the plug, and we're gonna, probably gonna take a short-term hit on, uh, ad revenue, and we don't have any basis for even forecasting what comes next because we've been milking the cost per click model for 20 years." And, uh, you know, their, probably their stock's gonna get hammered and, and, and it's just gonna be a rough period. But then they'll get back. I mean, I think that they'll still have a, a huge market share. They're not gonna have the same dominant market share, 90%, that they've had on search. Um, but they're still, th- they're still gonna be... I think they're gonna basically split the consumer market. The re- I think they're gonna split retail and consumer with, with ChatGPT basically
Simon: Well, I'm just asking mine how many, uh, ad account managers Does Google employ worldwide, right? So I don't know what
Paris: I'm gonna guess 20,000
Simon: Um, it hasn't given me an exact answer. Let me just... That's... 'Cause that's... Oh, sorry. Made a mistake. I'm on Bing.
Paris: Oh, okay
Simon: Let me just ask... I'm gonna ask Grok. Um, but my, my, my other point is if they, if they did what you've just said, as in we move straight away into, right, the whole game's changed. As
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: let's say it was January the 1st, 2027, we've just launched Google agentic commerce, and this is what you do, and it's all there, and it's
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: all love it. Um, so it says Google, uh, about 30,000 people in ad sales.
Paris: Oh, 30,000. Okay. Yeah
Simon: estimates 200,000... 42,000 in
Paris: Total
Simon: 200,000 Google staff, but that
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: over every product, etc., etc. But
Paris: Yeah
Simon: pickers, as I call them, you might not understand what I mean with... You'll understand in a second. You know those people, once you've got a Google account, and they phone you up and say, "Let's optimize your account, and we'll, you know, run a bunch more ads and some tests"?
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: all of them will go. They have to go. You know, they don't... Google would have to... could get rid of tens of thousands of staff on that day
Paris: Yeah
Simon: But it won't cover what they'll lose in terms of revenue, 'cause I don't know what it is, it's billions, right?
Paris: Yeah. Yeah, it's gonna be, it's gonna be a big hit. Um, and they're, uh, obviously be- being a public company and they're so short-term focused and they have to deliver results every quarter, uh, it's tough. I mean, OpenAI doesn't have that. They don't have the, the pressure of Wall Street looking for quarterly earnings because they're still a high-growth st- startup basically. So,
Simon: tell me in LinkedIn this week, "Oh, OpenAI won't be around next year because it's just a bubble and, you know, it's all hyped up and it doesn't produce results." And I went,
Paris: Hmm.
Simon: "Okay.
Paris: Show them, show them Anthropic's IPO from yesterday. It popped 30% on day one. The stock popped 30%. It's a $2 trillion company. Well, I, I think it drifted back down a little bit, but OpenAI's gonna have the same IPO in, in a couple more months. I mean, it's gonna be the same thing. It's gonna be 1.5 to 1.8 trillion valuation. It's gonna be massive. Uh, these investors, they-
Simon: not investment advice, right?
Paris: No, this is not investment advice, no. And, and I, uh, I, uh, actually didn't, didn't get in on Anthropic yet, but, uh, um, um, I have an itchy trigger finger for sure. I, I, I think it's maybe... It, it's probably the best business that has-- that we've seen since Google in the last 20 years, is, is Anthropic. And OpenAI is, is right there because OpenAI is gonna battle it out for the consumer with Google, and Anthropic is gonna battle it out with Microsoft for the enterprise, and that's it. It's gonna be that. That's the world
Simon: not investment advice, but I wouldn't be buying Google stock at the moment, and I would be buying because
Paris: Well, I'm, I'm still betting on Google because of their cloud infrastructure and their, their, um, the Google Cloud business is growing at 100% per year, and I think that even by next year, we might even see Google Cloud as a business surpass the Google advertising revenue, which would be amazing. Because Google Cloud is on an absolute tear. They've got the data centers. They have everything from land, power, shell, to the, uh, to the chips and the racks and the networking. They, they, they're vertically integrated all up and down the whole stack. So I just think that they're losing at the model... Right now, they're kinda losing at the model layer, and they have the legacy, they have the legacy ad business that's, uh, that's just kind of shriveling up on the vine.
Simon: The
Paris: But they do have
Simon: legacy ad business. That's what you've just described Google
Paris: Well, that's cost per click. Its, its days are numbered. We know this. So it's, you know, it's not a dinosaur yet, but it's
Simon: I, I had another client speak to me this week, and he's, he's spending 30K a month on Google CPC,
Paris: Mm-hmm.
Simon: words are, "It's no- it's, like, half as effective as it was six months ago."
Paris: Yeah.
Simon: he said that,
Paris: But he's still doing it
Simon: need to
Paris: Mm-hmm
Simon: AI. I've got to be in that listing."
Paris: Yep. Well, Simon, uh, I'll have to stop here, uh, but it's been a lot of fun as always. And, uh, we'll-- let's keep covering this, these stories every week and, uh, things are moving real fast. So, uh, it's been, it's been fun
Simon: Yeah, anytime. Have a great weekend
Paris: Same to you. Thanks, Simon. Okay