Which AEO Software Does AI Recommend?

SaaS AI Visibility Index · Answer Engine Optimization Software · Mixed company sizes · November 2026

We asked ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews the twenty questions that small, mid-sized and enterprise buyers ask when they choose an answer engine optimization (AEO) tool, thirty times each. Profound, Peec AI and Otterly.AI lead, and only 2 of G2’s 7 AEO Leaders are named in a quarter of AI answers.

2 of 7
G2 AEO Leaders named in at least a quarter of AI answers
66%
of answers name Profound, level with Peec AI and Otterly.AI
8
different tools win 19 of the 20 questions
1,162
AI answers analysed, 18 November 2026

The AI Visibility Grid: answer engine optimization software, mixed company sizes

Up: how often AI names the tool. Right: how early it names it, against what chance would give. Each dot is coloured by the tool’s G2 position.

AI Visibility Grid for answer engine optimization software: Profound and Peec AI named most often and early; only 2 of 7 G2 AEO Leaders named in a quarter of answers

Tap or click the grid to open it full size. Lines through each dot show its likely range. A dot whose lines cross the middle lines could sit in the next box, so read box positions as a guide, not a ranking.

Buyers now ask an AI assistant which tool will get them into AI answers, which makes this category a test of its own pitch. So we compared two leaderboards: who G2’s reviewers rank as leaders, and who ChatGPT and Google’s AI actually recommend. GEOforge is one of the vendors measured here. We measured ourselves with the same method, and neither engine named GEOforge in any of the 1,162 answers.

Which answer engine optimization software does AI recommend most?

  • Profound, Peec AI and Otterly.AI lead, level with each other. They are named in 66%, 66% and 64% of answers, and their ranges overlap. Semrush (61%) is level with Otterly.AI but behind the other two.
  • Ahrefs is a clear fifth at 41%. Then Scrunch AI (36%) and AthenaHQ (21%). After them, every tool appears in fewer than one answer in five.
  • Profound is AI’s default. It comes first in 47% of the answers that name it, and only it and Peec AI sit in the grid’s top-right box. Semrush, which AI lists as an SEO suite with AI tracking, comes first in only 13% of its mentions.
  • The engines agree on the leaders, less on the rest (rank correlation 0.60). ChatGPT names the specialist trackers far more often: Peec AI is in 83% of ChatGPT answers and 48% of Google’s, Scrunch AI in 57% and 13%. Google, in turn, names newer tools that ChatGPT never does: Sight AI (16% of Google answers), Indexly (9%) and Temso (8%).

ChatGPT leans harder on the specialists than Google does

Share of answers that name each tool, by engine. Hover a bar for the exact figure.

Profound
76%
56%
Peec AI
83%
48%
Otterly.AI
76%
51%
Semrush
72%
51%
Ahrefs
44%
37%
Scrunch AI
57%
13%
AthenaHQ
33%
8%
HubSpot AEO
19%
17%
SE Visible
12%
18%
Writesonic
8%
8%
Surfer SEO
7%
9%
AirOps
11%
5%
ChatGPT (600 answers)Google AI Overviews (562 searches)

Top 12 tools by share of all answers. Bars are scaled to 90%.

How we counted the broad suites. Semrush, Ahrefs and Similarweb sell much more than AI visibility tracking, and we count every mention of them, so part of their share is AI naming them as SEO or web-analytics tools. HubSpot counts only when an answer names its AEO product or its AI Search Grader, not the HubSpot CRM. Every tool’s G2 position here is on the AEO grid only.

Who wins each question?

Profound, mostly. In 19 of the 20 questions one tracked tool is the one AI names first most often, and 8 different tools share those wins. Profound takes 8, including the general and enterprise questions. Peec AI wins mid-sized companies, agencies, ecommerce and the head-to-head comparison. Otterly.AI wins small businesses and the easiest tool to set up, two questions where Profound is named in only 23% and 10% of answers. Semrush wins monitoring Google’s AI Overviews, HubSpot’s AEO tools free or low-cost tracking, Writesonic tools that also create content, Promptwatch tracking in several countries and languages, and Yext local businesses with several locations. The crawler question has no winner: all 59 answers point to robots.txt and Cloudflare’s crawler settings, and only 2 of them name a tracked tool at all.

Share of answers naming each tool, by question
QuestionProfoundPeec AIOtterly.AISemrushAhrefsScrunch AINamed first most often
Best AEO software85%81%92%95%53%63%Profound (64%)
Track my brand in AI100%100%100%82%92%68%Profound (65%)
Small business23%79%89%66%6%32%Otterly.AI (74%)
Mid-sized B2B97%66%24%68%34%49%Peec AI (42%)
Google AI Overviews77%65%83%95%70%3%Semrush (63%)
Free or low-cost5%58%84%28%42%2%HubSpot AEO (37%)
Agencies83%78%57%74%43%57%Peec AI (65%)
Get cited by AI88%72%86%74%67%47%Profound (69%)
Enterprise share of voice95%76%31%71%44%66%Profound (80%)
Also creates content50%18%27%68%15%17%Writesonic (53%)
Instead of SEO tools88%90%77%85%73%47%Profound (62%)
Brand vs competitors97%93%97%84%84%53%Profound (64%)
Ecommerce72%70%50%27%22%25%Peec AI (50%)
Compare, mid-sized87%95%97%68%52%53%Peec AI (48%)
Easiest to set up10%58%80%36%8%3%Otterly.AI (66%)
AI traffic to my site70%48%32%43%35%8%Profound (32%)
Fix wrong AI information68%65%72%42%40%53%Profound (51%)
Countries & languages96%83%70%76%22%57%Promptwatch (37%)
Can AI crawlers read my site0%0%0%2%2%0%No AEO tool
Local, several locations32%25%30%45%7%7%Yext (61%)

Do G2’s leaders get recommended by AI?

Two of them clearly do. G2’s Answer Engine Optimization grid lists 7 of the tools we tracked as Leaders. Profound (66%) and Semrush (61%) are among AI’s top four, and HubSpot AEO (18%) and SE Visible (15%) appear in more than one answer in ten. The other three, Birdeye (3%), Similarweb (1%) and Brandlight AI (0.9%), appear in fewer than one in twenty, though Similarweb and Birdeye have more than a thousand G2 reviews each. And three G2 High Performers, Hall, Visby AI and Quattr, never appeared at all.

G2 Answer Engine Optimization grid position vs how AI names each tool
ToolG2 quadrant (all segments)Named in AI answersLikely range *Average positionNamed first
ProfoundLeader66%64–68%2.247%
Peec AIHigh Performer66%64–68%2.620%
Otterly.AIHigh Performer64%62–66%3.317%
SemrushLeader61%59–64%4.013%
AhrefsContender41%39–43%4.39%
Scrunch AIHigh Performer36%34–37%4.12%
AthenaHQHigh Performer21%19–23%4.70.4%
HubSpot AEOLeader18%17–20%3.529%
SE VisibleLeader15%13–16%4.213%
WritesonicNiche8%7–9%3.235%
AirOpsContender8%7–9%4.211%
PromptwatchNiche7%6–9%3.324%
YextContender5%4–6%2.163%
RankscaleNot on the AEO grid5%4–6%4.44%
ConductorContender4%3–5%——
GoodieNot on the AEO grid4%3–5%——
EvertuneNot on the AEO grid4%3–5%——
BirdeyeLeader3%3–4%——
LLMrefsNot on the AEO grid3%2–4%——
BrightEdgeContender2%1–3%——
AIclicksHigh Performer2%1–3%——
SimilarwebLeader1%0.9–2%——
Brandlight AILeader0.9%0.5–2%——
Bluefish AINiche0.8%0.4–1%——
SearchableHigh Performer0.6%0.3–1%——
seoClarityNiche0.4%0.2–0.9%——
Search AtlasHigh Performer0.4%0.2–1%——
GEOforgeNiche0%0–0.3%——
HallHigh Performer0%0–0.3%——
KnowatoaNot on the AEO grid0%0–0.3%——
Visby AIHigh Performer0%0–0.3%——
QuattrHigh Performer0%0–0.3%——
GetCitoNiche0%0–0.3%——

* Likely range: AI gives a different answer each time, so we asked every question thirty times. If we asked these same questions again, the share would land inside this range 95 times in 100. It describes these questions only: a different set of questions could give different shares. When two tools’ ranges overlap, treat them as a tie. Average position is where the tool appears among the tools an answer names (1 = first); named first is the share of its own mentions in which it comes first. Both are shown only for tools named in at least 5% of answers and 20 times in all.

Where do G2 and AI disagree most?

Mostly on the specialists. Peec AI, Otterly.AI, Scrunch AI and AthenaHQ sit in G2’s High Performer quadrant, yet AI names each of them more often than five of the seven Leaders, and Peec AI and Otterly.AI are level with Profound at the top. Ahrefs, a G2 Contender, is named in 41% of answers. On the other side, three Leaders are close to invisible.

Where G2 and AI disagree
G2 Leaders AI rarely namesNamed in AI answersTools AI favours that G2 doesn’t rank as LeadersG2 positionNamed in AI answers
Birdeye3%Peec AIHigh Performer66%
Similarweb1%Otterly.AIHigh Performer64%
Brandlight AI0.9%AhrefsContender41%
Scrunch AIHigh Performer36%
AthenaHQHigh Performer21%
WritesonicNiche8%
AirOpsContender8%
PromptwatchNiche7%
YextContender5%
RankscaleNot on the grid5%

What does AI talk about when it recommends answer engine optimization software?

Coverage and citations, above all. 94% of answers talk about covering several AI engines (Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, Claude) and 91% about tracking which sources AI cites. Traditional SEO comes up in 83%: AI still frames this category against the SEO tools buyers already own. Competitor benchmarking (78%), Google AI Overviews and prompt tracking (72% each) follow, and price, dashboards, brand-mention tracking and actionable recommendations each appear in about two answers in three. Three things buyers asked about directly hardly come up: AI traffic to their site (23%), wrong or made-up information about their brand (10%) and ease of use (3%).

Coverage and citations lead what AI talks about

Share of answers that mention each topic, by engine.

Multiple AI engines
96%
92%
Citation tracking
96%
86%
Traditional SEO
91%
74%
Competitor benchmarking
94%
60%
Google AI Overviews
70%
75%
Prompt tracking
68%
76%
Dashboards and reporting
82%
54%
Brand mention tracking
84%
51%
Actionable recommendations
94%
34%
Price
82%
47%
Sentiment
50%
44%
Technical AI readiness
44%
51%
Share of voice
57%
30%
Content creation and optimization
36%
34%
Integrations
37%
27%
AI traffic and attribution
27%
18%
A free plan or trial
16%
10%
Hallucinations and accuracy
11%
8%
Ease of use
2%
4%
ChatGPTGoogle AI Overviews

Some questions ask about Google AI Overviews, competitors, content, free tools, AI traffic, wrong information, ease of setup or AI crawlers directly, which lifts those topics. ChatGPT answers are longer, so they mention most topics more often.

How does AI position each brand?

The leaders get distinct labels. In the lines that name them, Profound is framed around enterprise (33% of its mentions), Semrush, Ahrefs and SE Visible around traditional SEO, Otterly.AI around price (23%) and small businesses, and Writesonic around content creation. Peec AI, despite its reach, has no strong angle: price leads at 13%. A typical answer names 5 tools, and the one named first is most often Profound (33% of answers), more than twice as often as Peec AI (14%) or Otterly.AI (11%).

What AI talks about when it names each tool
ToolStressed mostAlso stressed
ProfoundEnterprise (33% of mentions)Citation tracking (12%), Prompt tracking (8%)
Peec AIPrice (13% of mentions)Prompt tracking (8%), Dashboards (6%)
Otterly.AIPrice (23% of mentions)Prompt tracking (8%), Small businesses (5%)
SemrushTraditional SEO (36% of mentions)Google AI Overviews (7%), Integrations (5%)
AhrefsTraditional SEO (26% of mentions)Brand mention tracking (5%), Google AI Overviews (5%)
Scrunch AIPrice (7% of mentions)Enterprise (7%)
AthenaHQPrice (10% of mentions)Recommendations (10%), Enterprise (5%)
HubSpot AEOMany AI engines (12% of mentions)Recommendations (9%), Integrations (5%)

“Stressed most” is the topic most often mentioned among those over-represented in the lines that name the tool, compared with all lines in all answers; the percentage is the share of those lines that mention it.

Where does AI get its information?

Not from review sites. 92% of ChatGPT answers cite at least one vendor’s own website, while only 2% cite a review site, and every one of those was G2. Beyond the vendors, ChatGPT leans on round-ups and on HubSpot: HubSpot’s blog (19% of answers) and its product pages, including its AEO tool and AI Search Grader (18%), and TechnologyAdvice’s “best AI search monitoring tools” (18%). Google’s AI Overviews lean on YouTube (40%), Reddit (25%) and LinkedIn (12%), and cite a review site in 3% of answers. That goes a long way to explaining the gap with G2: a review score only helps if AI reads it, and here it rarely does.

Which tools does AI name that buyers might not expect?

Specialists win the specific question. Yext is named first in 34 of 56 answers for local businesses with several locations, and gets 43 of its 59 mentions from that one question. Writesonic is named first in 32 of 60 answers about tools that also create content, Promptwatch in 20 of 54 about tracking several countries and languages, and HubSpot’s AEO tools in 21 of 57 about free or low-cost tracking. Not one of the four is in AI’s overall top six. Sight AI, which only Google names, comes first in 15 of 60 answers about content tools.

What does this mean if you sell answer engine optimization software?

  • A G2 Leader badge does not carry over into AI answers by itself. 3 of G2’s 7 AEO Leaders are named in fewer than 5% of answers, while two High Performers, Peec AI and Otterly.AI, sit level with Profound at the top.
  • Being named is not being recommended. Semrush is named in 61% of answers but first in only 13% of them; Profound is first in 47%. Track how early you are named, not just whether.
  • Your own website carries the most weight. ChatGPT cited a vendor’s own site in 92% of answers and a review site in 2%. Say plainly on your own pages who you are best for: that is the text AI quotes back.
  • The question decides the winner. 8 different tools win 19 of the 20 questions. Local businesses, international tracking, content and free tools each have their own leader.

How did we measure this?

We asked 20 unbranded questions that buyers of mixed company sizes ask, from small businesses to enterprises, fixed before any data was collected, thirty times each on ChatGPT (as a user sees it on chatgpt.com) and on Google search (AI Overviews), in US English, on 18 November 2026. That gave 600 ChatGPT answers and 562 Google searches, every one of which showed an AI Overview. This is the category’s first report on the index’s fixed list of twenty questions: questions 1 to 13 are the ones we first asked on 12 November, and 14 to 20 were added to complete the list. 38 Google fetches failed even after a retry and were excluded, so a few questions have fewer than thirty Google runs. We counted a tool as named when its name appears anywhere in the answer. The likely ranges show where each share would land, 95 times in 100, if we asked these same 20 questions again; they describe these questions, not every question a buyer might ask. Tools whose ranges overlap are a tie. On the grid, presence is the share of answers naming the tool, and prominence compares how early it is named with where a random order would put it (100 = chance). Topics and positioning come from matching keywords in the answer text. Sources are the links each engine attached to its answer; 24% of Google answers included unresolved Google redirect links, so Google’s source shares are lower bounds. G2 positions are from G2’s live Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) Tools grid, all segments view, captured on 12 November 2026. GEOforge publishes this index and is one of the tools measured; it was tracked with the same questions and rules as every other tool.

Show the 20 questions
#Question
P01What is the best answer engine optimization (AEO) software?
P02What are the best tools to track my brand's visibility in ChatGPT and other AI assistants?
P03Which generative engine optimization (GEO) platform would you recommend for a small business?
P04What's the best AI search visibility tool for a mid-sized B2B software company?
P05How can I monitor whether Google AI Overviews cite my website, and which tools do that?
P06What are the best free or low-cost tools for checking whether AI answers mention my brand?
P07Which AEO tools are best for marketing agencies that manage many clients?
P08What software helps get my content cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini?
P09What are the best enterprise platforms for tracking share of voice in AI search?
P10Which AI visibility tools also help create or improve content, not just measure it?
P11What should I use instead of traditional SEO tools to optimize for large language models?
P12Which tools show how AI assistants describe my brand compared with competitors?
P13What's the best AEO software for an ecommerce brand?
P14Compare the top AI search visibility platforms for a mid-sized company.
P15What's the easiest AEO tool to set up for a small marketing team with no technical background?
P16Which tools measure how much of my website traffic comes from ChatGPT and other AI assistants?
P17What tools help me fix wrong or outdated information that AI assistants give about my company?
P18Which AI visibility tools track my brand in several countries and languages?
P19What's the best tool to check whether AI crawlers can read my website, and what to fix if they can't?
P20Which AI search visibility tools are best for a local business with several locations?

Is your brand on the list?

GEOforge measures how often ChatGPT and Google’s AI recommend your brand for the questions your buyers actually ask, and how early, with the error margins to tell real change from noise.

Check your brand →

Sources & method. GEOforge SaaS AI Visibility Index, answer engine optimization software, mixed company sizes, 18 November 2026: 20 questions, 1,162 AI answers (ChatGPT via chatgpt.com and Google AI Overviews, US English), collected through DataForSEO. G2 Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) Tools grid (Live view, all segments), captured 12 November 2026.

GEOforge is one of the vendors measured here.